Group Scholar

Evaluation Toolkit

Rubric Kit for fair, fast, and human admissions decisions.

A compact playbook of criteria, interview prompts, and evidence signals so every scholarship review feels aligned, explainable, and bias-aware.

Download templates
Cycle cadence 2-hour build session
Ideal group 3–6 reviewers
Scholarship Rubric Score: 82

Community Impact

Evidence: peer letters, initiative ownership

High

Academic Momentum

Evidence: trend lines, grit markers

Steady

Need & Access

Evidence: context brief, barriers

Critical

Rubric modules

Pick the ones that fit your scholarship vision.

Values & Mission Fit

Define the decision principles that matter most to your program.

  • Mission alignment statements
  • Bias interruption checklist
  • Weighted criteria grid

Student Story Evidence

Map the evidence reviewers should look for in each application.

  • Artifact-based prompts
  • Context frames
  • Growth indicators

Review Calibration

Keep scoring consistent across evaluators and panels.

  • Score anchor examples
  • Calibration meeting agenda
  • Drift audit log

Fast workflow

Run a rubric sprint in one afternoon.

01

Align on mission

Share the scholarship goals and map to decision criteria.

02

Draft signals

List the evidence needed and the sources that prove it.

03

Calibrate

Test the rubric with sample applications and adjust weights.

04

Launch & review

Train reviewers, collect feedback, and refine each cycle.

Calibration studio

Align on anchors before real applications arrive.

15 min

Norm the rubric

Define what a 2, 4, and 5 look like for each signal.

30 min

Score sample files

Score three anonymized applicants together.

20 min

Resolve drift

Capture disagreements and update the anchors.

10 min

Set owner

Assign one reviewer to monitor drift each cycle.

Consensus Map

Anchor scoring guide

Live
5

Transformative

Evidence of system-level impact or leadership.

4

Strong

Consistent initiative and measurable momentum.

3

Promising

Early indicators with clear growth potential.

Template pack

Artifacts that make scoring clear and consistent.

Rubric Grid

Weighted rows, column anchors, and a score summary strip.

Sheet + PDF

Reviewer Brief

One-page context snapshot with bias interrupts and reminders.

One-pager

Interview Prompts

Evidence-seeking questions mapped to each signal.

Prompt list

Calibration Log

Track drift, disagreements, and resolution notes.

Notion-ready

Signal library

Evidence types that support more holistic evaluation.

Context Brief

Notes on environment, access, and constraints.

Impact Portfolio

Artifacts, testimonials, and initiatives led.

Momentum Notes

Trends, resilience stories, and recovery arcs.

Community Validation

Peer, mentor, and family perspectives.

Feedback loop

Capture reviewer sentiment, drift, and improvements after each cycle.

Feedback pulse

Live snapshot from reviewer submissions.

Totals

Total submissions
Follow-up ok
Last submission

Cycle stages

  • Loading...

Focus areas

  • Loading...

Latest notes

  • Loading...

Pulling most recent feedback.

Syncing with database.